Donate
Email Password
Not a member? Sign Up   Forgot password?
Business and Economics Education Environment Health Care California
Home
About PRI
My PRI
Contact
Search
Policy Research Areas
Events
Publications
Press Room
PRI Blog
Jobs Internships
Scholars
Staff
Book Store
Policy Cast
Upcoming Events
WSJ's Stephen Moore Book Signing Luncheon-Rescheduled for December 17
12.17.2012 12:00:00 PM
Who's the Fairest of Them All?: The Truth About Opportunity, ... 
More

Recent Events
Victor Davis Hanson Orange County Luncheon December 5, 2012
12.5.2012 12:00:00 PM

Post Election: A Roadmap for America's Future

 More

Post Election Analysis with George F. Will & Special Award Presentation to Sal Khan of the Khan Academy
11.9.2012 6:00:00 PM

Pacific Research Institute Annual Gala Dinner

 More

Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts
10.19.2012 5:00:00 PM
Author Book Signing and Reception with U.S. Supreme Court Justice ... More

Opinion Journal Federation
Town Hall silver partner
Lawsuit abuse victims project
Blog RSS Archive
E-mail Print Even Blue Cross/Blue Shield Likes Consumer-Driven Health Care


By: John R. Graham
10.21.2008

Recent Data Confirm Positive Trend in Take-Up

 

The latest presentation from the Blue Cross Blue Shield Association (BCBSA) continues the steady drumbeat of positive data about the take-up of consumer-driven health plans (CDHP), which has reached (fingers crossed) its tipping point.

It's an outstanding presentation, prepared by Maureen Sullivan, senior VP at BCBSA (with whom I'm not acquainted).  There's no point in my regurgitating it for you.  However, I've got some key take-aways that might differ somewhat from those that BCBSA would like you to retain.

  • The CDHP population now looks very similar to the non-CDHP population.  Fears of risk selection, i.e., that CDHPs are only for the young and healthy, are misplaced.
  • The benefits of the patient having "skin in the game" are not really very apparent unless the patient actually opens and has money in a Health Savings Account (HSA) or similar vehicle.  So, some "paternalism" from the employer in funding the account is often appropriate.
  • Price (to the patient, i.e. out-of-pocket cost) is the primary driver of decisions: not quality.  Even though BCBSA members (according to the presentation) are investing a lot in determining and communicating quality of providers, respondents did not really take this information into account.

I conclude (tentatively) that the money, which payers are investing in measuring and communicating quality (which BCBSA plans brand "Blue Distinction"), is largely misdirected.  Payers resist this conclusion fiercely, because it minimizes their value added, which doesn't really add much value, as I've argued before.

Imagine if your automobile insurer decided to tell you which was the right car to buy.  You'd tell Geico or Progressive, or whichever one it is, to stop wasting your money assessing the "quality" of different cars, and lower the premiums instead!  But the Government has screwed up health care far too much to expect a similar response from health plans.

In fact, when I read the press release from BCBSA, I had a response that often comes to me when I read about American health care: We discuss it in language that would be absurd in any other area of our lives.  Imagine this statement coming from the banking industry:

"People enrolled in consumer-directed banking (CDB) are more likely to budget for household costs, according to new survey results released by the American Bankers Association.  Collectively, American banks serve 4.4 million consumer-directed banking members - up 50% from last year.  Of these, 2.9 million have checking accounts and 1.5 million have savings accounts.  In order to grow the number of people who enrol in consumer-directed banking, as well as the number of CDB enrollees who ultimately open checking or savings accounts, banks and employers must continue to work together to share information with consumers on how they can best use CDB."

Ridiculous, right? But we are so far away from controlling our health care dollars that we have trouble seeing it.




 

Submit to: 
Submit to: Digg Submit to: Del.icio.us Submit to: Facebook Submit to: StumbleUpon Submit to: Newsvine Submit to: Reddit
Browse by
Recent Publications
Blog Archive
Powered by eResources