Donate
Email Password
Not a member? Sign Up   Forgot password?
Business and Economics Education Environment Health Care California
Home
About PRI
My PRI
Contact
Search
Policy Research Areas
Events
Publications
Press Room
PRI Blog
Jobs Internships
Scholars
Staff
Book Store
Policy Cast
Upcoming Events
WSJ's Stephen Moore Book Signing Luncheon-Rescheduled for December 17
12.17.2012 12:00:00 PM
Who's the Fairest of Them All?: The Truth About Opportunity, ... 
More

Recent Events
Victor Davis Hanson Orange County Luncheon December 5, 2012
12.5.2012 12:00:00 PM

Post Election: A Roadmap for America's Future

 More

Post Election Analysis with George F. Will & Special Award Presentation to Sal Khan of the Khan Academy
11.9.2012 6:00:00 PM

Pacific Research Institute Annual Gala Dinner

 More

Reading Law: The Interpretation of Legal Texts
10.19.2012 5:00:00 PM
Author Book Signing and Reception with U.S. Supreme Court Justice ... More

Opinion Journal Federation
Town Hall silver partner
Lawsuit abuse victims project
Publications Archive
E-mail Print Infantopia
Capital Ideas
By: K. Lloyd Billingsley
10.23.2003

Capital IdeasCapital Ideas

SACRAMENTO, CA - Yes, it is true that "we spent too much" as Lt. Gov. Cruz Bustamante candidly conceded on television during the recall campaign. Mr. Bustamante's cure for this problem, taking even more money from the people, did not find much favor with voters. But beyond the simple arithmetic, and the obvious truth that a state should not spend more than it takes in, lies a broader malaise.

In September, George Will observed that California resembles Britain in 1975, when "bad government by bothparties - meaning bad decisions by British voters- had brought that nation to the brink of bankruptcy. "While Britain was "the sick man of Europe," Will wrote, "California is the sick man of the Republic." The problem, in his view, is "infantilism."

"The public has repeatedly used the initiative process to mandate spending that prevents sane budgeting," Mr. Will said, "And the public has used this recall to throw a tantrum about what it, the public, has wrought." Willnoted in California a dearth of the "vigorous virtues" that rescued Britain under Margaret Thatcher, and which together can be called "adulthood."

These include entrepreneurship, deferral of gratification, individual initiative, and personal responsibility in making appetites conform to resources. California needs all that, but must also shed anotherprevailing ethos - utopianism.

Utopianism is the impulse that prompts politicians to launch policies that either have never been implementedelsewhere or have already proven disastrous. It is the notion that every problem has a political solution and that perfection is attainable through politics. It is the belief, tenaciously held, that a ruling political class can do great things for masses of people at no cost or adverse effect to the people themselves.

Under utopianism, a tax dollar can be sent to Sacramento, go out on the town, and return to a district with no loss whatsoever in bureaucratic overhead. Worst of all, under utopianism, ideas have no consequences. That is why the actual utopia is always just around the corner.

Before the recall, California received a vivid example of utopianism in action - a proposal for universal healthcare by state senator Sheila Kuehl. The measure was an open-ended entitlement, based on residency, with no deductibles or co-pays. It would have provided practically unlimited benefits, just about everything short of pedicures and plastic surgery on demand. The government would have been in total control and private insurance as we know it would no longer exist. The plan would have been financed by new taxes, but it came billed as free health care.

When Mark Paul of the Sacramento Bee interviewed Sen. Kuehl about the legislation, she "couldn't explain thedetails of her own bill." Yet, as Paul also noted, Kuehl recently contended that the Senate would have to save California from the "ignorance" of the new governor, who is getting called a lot of childish names these days.

Infantilism combined with utopianism makes for infantopianism. As the new administration, particularlythe auditors, will quickly discover, infantopianism has consequences. The cure will be difficult and painful. California needs to grow up and get real.



K. Lloyd Billingsley is editorial director of the Pacific Research Institute in San Francisco. He can be reached via email at klbillingsley@pacificresearch.org.


Submit to: 
Submit to: Digg Submit to: Del.icio.us Submit to: Facebook Submit to: StumbleUpon Submit to: Newsvine Submit to: Reddit
Within Publications
Browse by
Recent Publications
Publications Archive
Powered by eResources