College sports will never be the same.
The name, image, and likeness (NIL) era has brought both good and bad changes to the landscape. With those changes comes the need for new rules.
This fall, the Senate passed the Protect College Sports Act 77-22, the first bill of its kind to clear either chamber of Congress. It attempts to bring stability to college athletics through one uniform federal framework.
Despite that lopsided vote, however, it is almost certainly dead.
What It Does
Let’s start with the good.
The Protect College Sports Act would establish one federal standard to govern NIL, and athletes would keep the right to earn from their own name, image, and likeness without putting their scholarship or eligibility at risk.
Athletes would have five calendar years to play and one transfer to another school without penalty. A second transfer would cost them a season of eligibility, barring certain circumstances, such as a head coach leaving.
Agents would have to follow new rules. Their fees would top out at 5 percent, contracts would end with eligibility, and every certified agent would go into a public database.
Under the proposal, injured athletes would get the medical and financial support they deserve. Schools wouldn’t be able to cut a scholarship over an injury or a bad season. They would also have to cover sport-related medical bills during an athlete’s career and for five years after. Stories like Inky Johnson’s would look very different today than back in 2006. And doctors, not coaches, would make return-to-play calls.
Olympic sports would also get a lifeline. Since May 2024, more than 415 athletic programs have been eliminated. High revenue schools would have to maintain women’s and Olympic scholarships and roster spots at 2024-25 levels.
But the bill also overreaches.
It caps the Power Four conferences at 20 schools and forces any school that leaves to sit out three years as an independent before joining another. Washington has no business drawing conference maps.
Its revenue-sharing limit, roughly $21.6 million per school, is a salary cap in everything but name. Congress can’t impose a real one without calling athletes employees, so it caps what schools can share instead. This is an anticompetitive price control directly limiting the earnings potential of athletes.
What It Doesn’t Do
While the bill polices what athletes earn, it barely touches anyone else.
Everyone around college sports is cashing in: coaches, administrators, and even commentator Kirk Herbstreit’s golden retriever, who landed his own “NIL deal” with Hertz this season.
There’s no limit on coaching salaries, facility spending, or administrative bloat. Coaches can still leave for a bigger check; their players now can’t do the same without paying a price.
Most importantly, the bill dodges the central question: are athletes employees? Athletes should be treated as what they are, independent contractors, with no union. The House’s own college sports bill, the SCORE Act, said exactly that. And leadership pulled it from the floor twice. So, this bill stays “neutral.”
Rather than resolving the issue, the bill appears to avoid taking a position at all, to secure enough votes for passage. But it satisfies no one. Labor groups say it leaves athletes powerless, while House Republicans who back the idea still want changes before they’ll vote for it.
Why It Doesn’t Matter
First, it’s all about the math.
Democrats swept the November 3rd midterms, taking control of both chambers when the new Congress convenes in January. Until then, Republicans remain in control of a lame-duck House with few working days left, most of which are already committed to the budget and the defense bill. GOP leaders want changes to the legislation, but any revisions would send it back to the Senate, where its prospects are even dimmer. Incoming Democratic leadership opposes the bill, making passage increasingly unlikely. As one lobbyist who works with Power Four schools put it to USA Today: “It’s dead.”
Second, even if the bill passes, it will leave many of the underlying problems in college sports unresolved. It places restrictions on athletes without imposing comparable limitations on coaches, boosters, or university administrators.
Third, ask who’s cheering loudest.
The NCAA spent decades fighting athlete pay. It lost 9-0 at the Supreme Court and gave up ground only when courts and state legislatures forced it to. Now it’s one of this bill’s biggest backers. That’s no coincidence. The bill hands the NCAA federal antitrust protection to enforce pay caps, transfer limits, and eligibility rules, the same power the courts stripped away.
When the governing body that resisted reform the hardest becomes its loudest champion, it’s worth asking who the bill really protects.
The Bottom Line
The Protect College Sports Act trades one set of problems for another. It brings real order to transfers, agents, and NIL while handing Washington control it shouldn’t have and dodging the questions that matter most.
Whatever happens with the bill, the work isn’t done. The next Congress will have to do better.
Brandon J. Winegarden is a Research Associate at the Pacific Research Institute.