California Already Won the Data Center Fight. Now Don’t Blow It.

Tech pexels cottonbro 5474025

Voters didn’t reject the internet. They rejected getting stuck with somebody else’s tab. California already fixed the tab. Please don’t fix it into a ban.

Election night was rough for data centers. Breakup-text-at-2-a.m. rough.

Before the votes, polling looked bad but fixable. In mid-October the Rainey Center found 56 percent of voters opposed a data center in their community, and a NetChoice survey by Echelon Insights put it at 58 percent. Then the exit polls landed.

NBC found 76 percent opposed one nearby. AP and Fox said about three-quarters. Local restrictions passed in 40 of 41 ballot measures. That gap is not a polling miracle, and nobody needs a conspiracy board with red string to explain it.

Surveys that put “AI” in the question ran hot all year: Gallup found 70 percent opposed in the spring, and California, as usual, got there first, with PPIC at 73 percent in July. The Rainey and NetChoice surveys asked about plain old data centers. By November, voters weren’t thinking about plain old data centers anymore. Every data center had become an AI data center.

Here’s the twist. The anti-data center, anti-AI team barely had to make its argument. The pro-data center argument never got made at all. When the NetChoice poll told voters what these buildings actually run (banking apps, hospital records, the military), support jumped from 33 to 44 percent. And 48 percent said tech companies’ pledges to pay for their own power made them more likely to back new data center investment.

Rainey found a data center for email, streaming and banking wins 47 to 40. Slap “AI” on the same building and it loses 36 to 54. Same servers. Worse branding. It’s the same building with a worse dating profile.

Meanwhile voters sat through $173 million in almost entirely negative ads about data centers, and the ad trackers couldn’t find a single one making the case for them. Pro-innovation forces ghosted the electorate, then acted shocked when they got dumped.

“Affordability” seems to be the story. Shocking, I know. Only 9 percent of voters in the NetChoice survey called regulating AI a top priority. Fifty-five percent picked the cost of living. Exit polls ranked AI and data centers dead last of five issues. Yet 55 percent told Rainey that data centers are pushing up their power costs.

In California that lands hard, because Californians already pay about 32 cents a kilowatt-hour, nearly double the rest of the country. That is not a data center problem. That’s a California problem with years of receipts: wildfire costs, climate programs and policy choices made long before anyone said “large language model.”

Now the part that matters for 2027, so look up from your phone for a second.

California, for once, has already made the right moves. In September, Newsom signed seven bills that make data centers pay for their own grid and generation costs, plus a share of the wildfire and program costs that usually land on everyone else’s bill. The California Public Utility Commission has until January 2028 to write those tariffs. That is the deal voters said they wanted.

The danger is that Sacramento and every city council decide it wasn’t enough. The new laws already strip exemptions from the state’s environmental review standards and adds discretionary review even where zoning says yes. Monterey Park banned data centers outright, and Los Angeles County has a temporary ban in unincorporated areas. Governor-elect Becerra promises “firm guardrails” without saying where they go. Very reassuring.

Pile moratoriums on top of all that and you don’t get fewer data centers. You get fewer data centers in California. Here’s what that costs.

Phones do not care where the server lives. You will still stream, scroll, bank and beg a chatbot to fix your cover letter. The computing just gets built in Nevada, Arizona or Texas, which JLL expects to pass Northern Virginia as the world’s biggest data center market by 2030. California keeps the demand and exports the paychecks for California electricians and construction crews. The tax base that funds everything Sacramento loves to hold a press conference about, that goes too.

The industry says it already supports about 665,000 California jobs and $14 billion a year in taxes. Salt those numbers to taste, but the direction isn’t in doubt. And the giant customer that was supposed to help cover the grid’s fixed costs? It plugs in somewhere else, and those costs stay on your bill.

So, Sacramento: write the tariffs, then put the pen down. Slowly. The hospital, the bank and the group chat depend on that.

Voters didn’t reject the internet. They rejected getting stuck with somebody else’s tab. California already fixed the tab. Please don’t fix it into a ban.

Bartlett Cleland is a senior fellow in tech and innovation at the Pacific Research Institute.

Nothing contained in this blog is to be construed as necessarily reflecting the views of the Pacific Research Institute or as an attempt to thwart or aid the passage of any legislation.

Scroll to Top