As Tax Day approaches, Americans rummage for misplaced receipts and dread any letters from the Internal Revenue Service. Most Americans remain unaware that for almost a century America got along just fine with no federal income tax at all.
To help fund the Civil War, the federal government introduced its first federal income tax as part of the Revenue Act of 1861. This tax was very modest by modern standards, imposing a flat rate of 3 percent on all incomes above $800. This tax was rescinded in 1872, and in 1895 the Supreme Court ruled that federal taxation of income derived from property had to be apportioned among the states.
For all practical purposes, it would take a constitutional amendment before the federal government could once again lay claim to the income of individual citizens. The opportunity came soon enough.
In 1913, the 16th Amendment ushered in the federal income tax as we know it. Originally, its scope was timid. The top bracket was a mere 7 percent, and it only applied to incomes above $500,000 — a fantastic sum at the time. The vast majority of Americans fell in the lowest tax bracket (up to $20,000), and owed the federal government a piddling 1 percent tax on their income.
Some skeptics warned that the government could not be trusted, and that the introduction of a federal income tax would prove to be a tragic mistake. The proponents of the new tax dismissed such concerns and promised that the tax was nothing but a slight inconvenience on the titans of industry. The skeptics quickly proved correct.
By 1918, just five years after the income tax was introduced, the government had jacked up the top rate to an astonishing 77 percent. Taxpayers in the lowest bracket saw their rate jump up from the original 1 percent in 1913 to 6 percent five years later. Government now deploys the income tax as a major source of revenue, and the tax code abounds in perverse incentives.
In fiscal year 2009, the federal government collected $2.1 trillion in tax revenues, of which 43 percent came from taxes on the incomes of individuals. Besides this enormous transfer of resources from taxpayers to government coffers, one must consider the income and wealth never produced in the first place.
The higher the marginal tax rate, the more defensive businesses and individuals become. They spend their time looking for loopholes, shielding their income and lobbying for tax breaks. Think of the millions of man hours of professional labor, in the form of tax attorneys, accountants and lobbyists, that could be devoted to something intrinsically useful like satisfying consumers were it not for the looming threat of an IRS audit or a new tax law.
As they fill in their returns, Americans would do well to reflect on tax history. The abrupt raise from 1 percent to 6 percent, for example, should be kept in mind when politicians propose a new tax on carbon dioxide, or when they reassure us that they’ll get spending under control. Those who ultimately pay the bills have a right and obligation to ask hard questions.
In light of the visible and invisible burdens of the federal income tax, it’s worth asking: What do we get in exchange?
Are most Americans pleased with the way the federal government operates? When they look at their pay stubs to see how much has been withheld, do American workers consider it money well spent?
On Tax Day, and at all times, taxpayers need to realize that the government can only give them what it has first taken away. Why not cut out the middleman by abolishing the federal income tax? Those early Americans were on to something.
Robert P. Murphy is senior fellow in business and economic studies at the conservative Pacific Research Institute in San Francisco.
This article also appeared in the following publications. Title of article may vary.
PostStar.com (Glenn Falls, NY), April 5, 2010
Juneau Empire (AK), April 5, 2010
Vindy.com (Youngstown, OH), April 6, 2010
NorthJersey.com (Woodland Park, NJ), April 5, 2010
McClatchy Newspapers (Washington, D.C.), April 2, 2010
Modesto Bee, April 4, 2010
Arkansas Democratic Gazette, April 5, 2010
Observer Dispatch (Utica, NY), April 9, 2010
Free Lance-Star (Fredericksburg, VA), April 9, 2010
Sun Herald (MS), April 10, 2010
Athens Banner Herald (GA), April 11, 2010
Augusta Chronicle (GA), April 11, 2010