Sally Pipes at Intelligence Squared Debate on “Medicare for All” (New York, NY)

September 17, 2019
115 East 68th Street, New York, NY, USA
150320221647327618

ABOUT THE DEBATE

Motion: Replace Private Insurance With “Medicare for All”

As the nation gears up for the 2020 election, Democrats are promising bold new changes to the American health care system. One idea championed by many on the progressive left is “Medicare for All,” or a single-payer system, which would do away with private health insurance for most forms of care. Advocates of this plan promise that nationalizing health insurance will cut costs by reducing overhead and promote overall health by giving all Americans access to preventive health care. And in doing so, the United States will join the ranks of many other developed nations that have already mandated a national insurance program to guarantee medical care as a basic human right. Their opponents argue Medicare for All is a political non-starter that would force Americans off employer-based plans, reduce incentives for doctors and providers, increase bureaucracy and inefficiencies in the system, and lead to worse care overall, all the while inflating the already swelled federal deficit. Should private health insurance exist? Or is it time for Medicare for All?

 

Click Here for More Information

 

 

 

FOR THE MOTION

Dr. Adam Gaffney
President, Physicians for a National Health Program

 

Joseph Sanberg
Co-Founder, Aspiration & Chair, CalEITC4Me

 

AGAINST THE MOTION

Sally Pipes
President, CEO, and Thomas W. Smith Fellow in Health Care Policy, PRI

 

Nick Gillespie
Editor-at-Large, Reason

 

THE HOST

John Donvan
Host and Moderator

 

ABOUT INTELLIGENCE SQUARED

A nonpartisan, nonprofit organization, Intelligence Squared U.S. is a debate series working to restore civility, reasoned analysis, and constructive public discourse to today’s media landscape. Click here for more information.

Tell Your Friends

Related

Lacking oversight: How to fix California’s system for selecting judges

Lacking oversight: How to fix California’s system for selecting judges By Michael Warnken | May 29, 2026 California’s judicial selection process has undergone significant changes ...
housing regulation photograph housing being built with ba7dfe62 b733 464f a4ca 16d4d34931aa 3

Read the latest from PRI's Free Cities Center

Albuquerque’s fumble on modest upzoning to promote housing

With a projected housing need of 55,000 new units by 2045, the city has passed some minor housing reforms in recent years, including legalizing accessory ...
NextRoundSquareNew

Next Round’s 2026 California Primary Preview

This week, Tim previews next week’s California primary election.  He takes a deep dive on the governor’s race and explores whether Xavier Becerra has unstoppable ...
Scroll to Top