POST-ELECTION REPORT
Will democratic socialist mayors pursue ideology or pragmatism?
By Sal Rodriguez
A specter is haunting some of America’s cities — the specter of democratic socialism.
On November 3, the list of democratic socialist mayors got longer, as Los Angeles Councilmember Nithya Raman prevailed in her challenge to Mayor Karen Bass and Washington, D.C. Councilmember Janeese Lewis George cruised to victory with over 80% of the vote.
Raman and Lewis George join New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Seattle Mayor Katie Wilson, who were elected in November 2025, as big-city democratic socialist mayors swept into office in the last year. Also elected in the November 2026 elections was Rhode Island state Representative David Morales as mayor of Providence.
All five describe themselves as democratic socialists, although only Raman, Lewis George and Mamdani received endorsements from their respective Democratic Socialists of America chapters.
But what does that mean, exactly, and how does it map onto the responsibilities of overseeing a municipal government?
Their explanations of what democratic socialism means to them are often less illuminating than their actual policy views.
To articulate his worldview, Mamdani has quoted Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.: “Call it democracy or call it democratic socialism. There has to be a better distribution of wealth for all of God’s children in this country.”
Raman, meanwhile, has spoken in more familiar ideological terms, but with little precision.
“I want the city to work and when the government is doing its job it needs to work really effectively, and we need to make sure capitalism works without harm to workers, without worker exploitation, without exploitation of poor people,” Raman told CNN’s Elex Michaelson ahead of the election. In that same interview, Raman described democratic socialism as a “big tent” and that she was also a capitalist.
There are some obvious implications from these types of framings, but, again, they’re mayors or mayors-elect, not presidents or commissars.
Rent control
To take housing policy as an example, all five mayors and mayors-elect support rent control, although their views merely map into standard big-city progressive politics.
Los Angeles, New York City and Washington, D.C., have long had some form of rent control on the books. Washington state law has preempted cities from setting their own rent control policies since the 1980s, but last year the state set its own statewide limits on rent increases.
Morales’ election in Providence will likely prove more significant, as there has been an active debate over rent control. Indeed, Morales prevailed over Mayor Brett Smiley, who in April vetoed a rent-control ordinance passed by the City Council.
“I don’t think there’s anything extreme about focusing around the needs of working people as it relates to making sure that they don’t get priced out of the community that they love calling home, which is why I’m a firm supporter of capping rent hikes at 4% a year,” Morales said after his victory.
Social housing
But where they really stand apart from standard progressive city officials is their shared enthusiasm for social housing. Social housing generally refers to housing that is publicly, nonprofit or cooperatively owned and maintained as affordable housing.
All five have indicated support for the concept, and in Wilson’s case Seattle voters explicitly approved city-run social housing before she became mayor.
Mamdani’s “Block by Block” plan calls for tens of billions of dollars in spending to build and preserve affordable housing units across the city. He also recently signed legislation granting nonprofit housing organizations and community trusts the first chance to buy distressed and rent-controlled multifamily housing if they’re ever sold.
“Providence can no longer leave the future of our housing supply solely in the hands of private developers,” declared Morales.
Lewis George has also declared she “will launch Dignified Homes DC, a bold commitment to build publicly owned, mixed-income housing with stable and affordable rents that put people ahead of profit.”
Finally, Raman has said she will use public funds “and city-owned land to build housing the city keeps in public hands, with affordable rents and residents at the table in how their buildings are run.”
While all five clearly prioritize government action on this front, at least Raman and Wilson nod at the importance of private-sector housing through their general support for all-of-the-above solutions to their respective cities’ housing crunches.
“We need the private market to build a lot more housing around the city in order to address our housing shortage,” Wilson said ahead of her election, and as mayor she has recently moved to streamline housing production.
Permitting reform
Perhaps more surprisingly, several of them, with the exception of Morales, have also embraced and emphasized proposals to streamline permitting processes, both for housing and for commercial activity.
Mamdani’s OPEN for Small Business initiative, for example, scrapped 50 rules for small businesses, including a mandate that restaurants get a specific dairy permit so they can sell ice cream. He also championed the recently approved Question 4 which aims to streamline dozens of construction permitting and approval processes. “New Yorkers voted for a government that moves as fast as they do,” he said upon its passage.
Lewis George has likewise vowed to streamline D.C.’s permitting processes and “launch a digital portal for one-stop licensing, reporting, permits, and other regulatory requirements.”
Raman has called for a shot clock on commercial permitting decisions, expanding self-certification options and making outdoor dining “free and simple.”
And while Wilson has at times done herself no favors with the local business community, she has convened a task force to evaluate, among other things, streamlining the city’s permitting processes and creating a one-stop shop for permitting issues.
Transit ideas
One notable area where they have seemingly subverted expectations is on public transit. While calls for “free transit” have grown in popularity in progressive circles, only Mamdani vowed to make an entire medium of transportation “free,” in his case buses. Since such a decision would actually require buy-in from the state, Mamdani’s vision of free buses has stalled in favor of a joint plan with the state to boost bus service.
The others, though, have prioritized service expansion and targeted aid.
Lewis George has called for “free transit for those who need it,” in D.C.’s case local residents enrolled in the SNAP program. Wilson just successfully led the passage of a sales tax to fund expanded services and subsidies for low-income residents. Morales has called for more investments in the city’s transit system and partnering with the Rhode Island Public Transit Authority to provide free bus passes for students, but not universal free transit.
In Los Angeles, it was actually Bass who called for “free transit,” while the democratic socialist challenger Raman ran on better management of the region’s Metro system and promoting increased bus service.
Here, they generally seem to be erring on a more pragmatic position of targeted aid rather than committing themselves to costly and counterproductive universal free transit schemes.
Looking ahead
While it’s too early to make many sweeping conclusions about how these particular mayoralties will play out, there are some obvious and less obvious takeaways.
One is that these democratic socialist mayors and mayors-elect value government intervention in a way that exceeds what a typical city would do or even could do without state law changes or broader partnerships with regional government actors. But they aren’t necessarily absolutists on government action — as their nuances on permitting, transit and even housing show.
One complication is that these mayors have been elected in already very blue cities, so parsing what they’re doing because they’re democratic socialists in particular versus a standard-issue progressive is less apparent given the considerable overlap.
Ultimately, one might suspect that they will be at their best when they operate as pragmatic actors rather than ideological showcases. No one should be shocked when efforts like top-down government housing schemes end up being quite expensive and less useful than permitting and zoning reforms. But, for now, all we can do is watch and they and their constituents figure things out from here.
Sal Rodriguez is opinion editor for the Southern California News Group and a senior fellow with the Pacific Research Institute. He is the author of “Dynamism or Decay? Getting City Hall Out of the Way,” published by the Pacific Research Institute.