Hoping That Water Ahead Isn’t a Mirage

California should not be suffering through an unending series water crises, but decades of mismanagement and politics have transformed the “essence of life” into liquid gold.

California is an unusually thirsty state, with more than 39 million people needing water for drinking, bathing and cleaning, and 70,000 farms requiring a steady supply of a most-scarce resource. But finally, after decades of neglect, California’s water storage will be getting a needed boost. Regulators have approved permits for a pair of large dams and several smaller ones that will harness the plentiful supplies of the Sacramento River.

It’s a landmark event — unless the project follows the same path as the perpetually bogged-down high-speed rail.

The state Water Resources Control Board has voted unanimously to move ahead with a project at the Sites Reservoir on the west side of the Sacramento Valley. The plan calls for two 300-foot dams and nine more that will be from 20 to 100 feet high. It will be the largest water storage facility to come online in California since the New Melones reservoir was finished in the late 1970s. Construction should begin next year and be completed in 2034.

As if to underscore how hard it is to build public works infrastructure in California, it’s taken a dozen years for the light to turn green.

The expansion was approved by Proposition 1 in 2014, when two of three voters said yes to issuing more than $7 billion in bonds to boost the state’s water supply. Many were likely fed up with California’s perpetual manmade droughts, water-use restrictions and some of the highest water prices in the country — as well as the growing “scarcity mindset” that has also caused supply troubles with electricity and petroleum products, which California consumes more of than any other state other than Texas.

It’s scandalous that it took 12 years to get the go-ahead from authorities who seem to believe their mission is to keep Californians parched. William Mulholland completed the 233-mile Los Angeles Aqueduct six years after city voters approved a bond issue for one of the most consequential projects in the state’s history.

California should not be suffering through an unending series water crises, but decades of mismanagement and politics have transformed the “essence of life” into liquid gold. The new storage will help — but not for more than seven years and even then it’s not certain that it will be enough to meet future needs. Senate Bill 72 set a target of 9 million acre-feet of new water supplies by 2040. The new dams will provide only about 1.3 million to 1.5 million acre-feet of water.

Outgoing Sen. Anna Caballero, the Merced Democrat who introduced SB 72 last year, before the Water Resources Control Board’s Sites decision, has said that “without state intervention,” California will have annual water shortages of 4.6 million to 9 million acre-feet by 2050. Yet even with this latest “intervention,” more will be needed.

It’s crucial that policymakers put in the work that will bridge this gap. The state’s economy, in fact its entire future, depends on a reliable and affordable supply of water. California needs the abundance mindset of previous generations that made it a destination rather than the scarcity mindset that has made it more of a point of departure for many hoping to escape the effects of poor public policy.

Naturally, no story about a large-scale California project, either public and private, would be complete without controversy and resistance. Eco-activists argue the project “threatens the health of the Sacramento River and San Francisco Bay-Delta” and will “raise river temperatures and worsen downstream water quality.” They’d rather California continue to go dry.

But as PRI fellow Steven Greenhut has pointed out, “environmental justice” starts when more water is provided for everyone. “Communities,” he says, especially those where incomes are low, “cannot flourish without abundant water.”

It’s a sensible notion that should be written down, framed and hung in the halls of government across the state.

Kerry Jackson is the William Clement Fellow in California Reform at the Pacific Research Institute.

Nothing contained in this blog is to be construed as necessarily reflecting the views of the Pacific Research Institute or as an attempt to thwart or aid the passage of any legislation.

Scroll to Top