Sukses Main Mahjong Ways Best808 Pahami Scatter dan Kombinasinya Mahjong Ways Best808 Simbol Scatter Meningkatkan Peluang Menang Kesalahan Umum Pemain Mahjong Ways di Best808 Auto Jackpot Strategi Terbaik Fitur Scatter Mahjong Ways Best808 Mahjong Ways Best808 Panduan Scatter Wild Hasil Maksimal Pola Mahjong Ways Best808 Gacor Scatter Menang Bongkar Misteri Mahjong Ways Best808 Kunci Kemenanganmu Mau Cuan Maksimal di Mahjong Ways Best808 Trik Menggunakan Scatter Agar Lebih Untung Main Mahjong Ways di Best808 Kenali Pola Scatter Free Spin Gandakan Kemenanganmu Rahasia Scatter Mahjong Ways Best808 Strategi Jitu Menang Jackpot Besar Misteri Scatter Mahjong Ways Tol777 Kunci Jackpot Besar Bongkar Rahasia Mahjong Ways Tol777 Fitur Scatter Pola Menang Mahjong Ways Tol777 Simbol Scatter Kemenangan Besar Main Mahjong Ways di Tol777 Cara Memanfaatkan Scatter Strategi Mahjong Ways Tol777 Rahasia Scatter Trik Menang Jackpot Analisis Pola Permainan Mahjong Ways Keunggulan Mahjong Ways Tol777 vs Tradisional Kombinasi Simbol Tertinggi Mahjong Ways Langkah Meningkatkan Keahlian Mahjong Ways Mahjong Ways Tol777 Berbeda dari Permainan Mengapa Mahjong Ways Tol777 Diminati Dunia Optimalkan Putaran Mahjong Ways Tol777 Sejarah Mahjong Ways Tol777 dan Keunikan Simbol Mahjong Ways Tol777 dan Pemanfaatannya Strategi Lanjutan Mahjong Ways Tol777 Live RTP Dan Kasino Online Live RTP Dan Kasino Online Live RTP Dan Kasino Online Live RTP Dan Kasino Online Live RTP Dan Kasino Online Live RTP Dan Kasino Online Live RTP Dan Kasino Online Live RTP Dan Kasino Online Live RTP Dan Kasino Online Live RTP Dan Kasino Online Cara Cepat Kuasai Mahjong Ways Tol777 Mengapa Mahjong Ways Tol777 Populer Mitos & Fakta Mahjong Ways Tol777 Strategi Pemula vs Pro Mahjong Ways Teknik Profesional Mahjong Ways Tol777 Mahjong Ways Tol777: Keberuntungan atau Skill? Mahjong Ways Tol777: Tradisi dan Inovasi Panduan Mahjong Ways Tol777 untuk Pemula Rahasia Menang Mahjong Ways Tol777 Tips Efektif Main Mahjong Ways Tol777 Kasino Online Kasino Online Kasino Online Kasino Online Kasino Online Kasino Online Kasino Online Kasino Online Kasino Online Kasino Online main mahjong ways di malam hari jackpot profit mengamati permainan mahjong ways dengan baik dan benar merasa bosan pada malam hari? coba cara bermain mahjong ways ini minum kopi memotivasi bermain mahjong ways nelayan tebing tinggi pola mahjong ways hasil mencengangkan pelajar bandung download mahjong ways peluang besar trik dan pola mahjong ways pemuda belanda tato mahjong ways mengenang jackpot satu miliar pola rtp mahjong ways terbaik resep bermain mahjong ways dengan mudah slot mahjong ways dikenal sejak abad ke-11 hingga zaman milenial video mahjong ways viral menghebohkan warga indonesia warga jayamakmur dulu diremehkan, bermain mahjong ways hidup berlimpah harta unik keren bali cendera mata mahjong ways rp100000 warga bingung merek cat dinding sama mahjong ways RTP LIVE RTP LIVE RTP LIVE RTP LIVE RTP LIVE RTP LIVE RTP LIVE RTP LIVE RTP LIVE RTP LIVE

There’s No Such Thing as Free Public Transportation Either

Whether it’s suspending the gas tax, $400 gift cards, or $200 refund checks – these proposals to help Californians cope with high gas prices all have varying degrees of merit.  But free public transportation? That was a real head scratcher.

Gov. Newsom, in his $11 billion relief package for Californians, announced that in addition to rebates for taxpayers, he proposes to spend “$750 million in incentive grants to transit and rail agencies to provide free transit for Californians for 3 months.”  If public transportation agencies actually do spend the money the way Newsom hopes (remember it’s just an incentive), roughly three million Californians per day who take the bus, subway, or light rail won’t have to pay fares for three months.

It’s obvious that people who take public transit don’t need relief from high gas prices any more than people who don’t own a car, like me.  What’s really going on here is a heavy dose of social engineering, sprinkled with a little commuter equity.  Politically, there’s got to be something in it for everyone: people who pump gas, people who don’t pump gas, and people who don’t want us to pump gas.

For decades, progressives and climate change activists have tried to get more people to take public transportation. And Newsom is not letting this gas price crisis go to waste.  By offering free public transportation, he hopes that he can help break up Californians’ life-long love affair with their cars.

But do people really drive less when public transportation is free?  Recent studies say no, but ridership does increase.

Some economists believe that free public transportation doesn’t make sense because it generates “useless mobility.” This means, writes Enrica Papa, associate professor of Transport Planning of the University of Westminster, “people will choose to move more simply because it’s free….”

That’s exactly what happened in Santiago, Chile.  A study by the Universidad Catolica de Chile showed that commuters who received free public transit passes didn’t drive any less but instead took advantage of the free fares during off-peak hours to have some fun. Chileans visited parks, went shopping, and dined at restaurants.

Prof. Papa notes that research has found that when public transit is free, “only a small number of people who previously travelled by car make the switch.  New passengers attracted by [the free fares] tend to be pedestrians and cyclists rather than car drivers.  The picture from most cities where free public transport has been introduced is that the increased passenger numbers overwhelmingly come from people who might have walked, cycled or not travelled otherwise.”

All this free transportation, she writes, ends up “increasing the costs of transport operators and subsidies to local authorities, while ultimately increasing emissions from public transport.”

Governor Newsom might want to pay special attention to Prof. Papa’s last point.

There’s also another, dangerous reason not to provide free transit.  Even more homeless people will be enticed to make the rails and buses a hangout. In the Los Angeles transit system alone, there are hundreds of encampments on or near Metro-owned property, facilities, and rights-of-way. The agency counted 5,700 homeless riders on their system in August 2021.

Steve Fiechter, a director with Metro’s outreach program run by People Assisting the Homeless, or PATH, told the Los Angeles Times that “homeless riders are often more isolated and have more serious behavioral issues than those living in encampments on the streets. Riders complain about harassment and disturbing outbursts, about soiled seats and elevators reeking of urine.” In Los Angeles earlier this year, a homeless man murdered a 70-year old nurse and avid transit user.  A man was also pushed onto the tracks and suffered a head injury and fractured ribs.

Milton Friedman famously warned us that there’s no such thing as a free lunch.  There’s no such thing as free public transportation either – it costs more, increases emissions, and worst of all becomes a risk to transit users.

Rowena Itchon is senior vice president of the Pacific Research Institute.

Nothing contained in this blog is to be construed as necessarily reflecting the views of the Pacific Research Institute or as an attempt to thwart or aid the passage of any legislation.

Scroll to Top